Loading...
The Cry of the Third Sex -part 1 The Cry of the Third Sex -part 1
Posted in: Tags:
Saida's picture

I am a human rights defender and I believe that we are all created equal and deserve to be treated with dignity. I also believe that as a human rights worker, I do not choose what rights to defend and what not to give attention to.

 A few days ago, I was shocked to read that every third day, a trans person is murdered (www.feministing.com , July 22nd 2009). This is based on a report that has just been released on violence against trans people worldwide. This is just what is reported. According to the report, released by Transgender Europe (TGEU) in a collaborative project with Liminalis through their project titled 'Trans Murder Monitoring Project', " the very preliminary results of the first step of this project have revealed a total of 204 cases of reported murders of trans people worldwide in the last one and half years. 121 cases of murdered trans people have been reported in 2008. From January to June 2009 already 83 cases of murdered trans people have been reported". One case of killing is one too many! Although this research has been conducted by groups based in the North, I would not be surprised to find that some of the cases reported actually occurred in the Global South.

My shock in reading those bits and pieces of the report was that this is a bad trend in that the violations of the rights of trans and intersex persons are likely to heighten based on the cultural and religious fundamentalisms that are on the rise in countries like Kenya. The lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender and intersex (LGBTI) people are the target of human rights violations in Kenya , which is also the case worldwide. We refuse to accord other people the right to enjoy their rights and freedoms based on misconceptions and fear that some people are courageous enough to challenge the status quo or supremacy of the male sex.   This is about  accepting sexual and gender diversities, and bodily integrity; respecting choice, understanding complex identities, protecting minorities and allowing individuals to realize theor full potential. For as long as there exists discriminative practices, certain individuals and their human rights will not thrive in our society. Or sections of our society refuse to accord others the space to thrive.

Over the last few months, there has been an increase in the number of cases of social injustices and discrimination against trans- and intersex people. In instances where the media has reported some cases of intersex persons, it has been in pointing to the cultural and social inhibitions that have led to the discrimination and the violations of the rights to education, health and security of intersex persons and/or their immediate relatives in cases where the intersex person is a minor.  Children who are intersex are reported not to be taken to school and in some instances, drop out of school due to ridicule by their peers and teachers.  Some of them have even conteplated committing suicide as they blame themselves for the wrongs projected unto them. There are reported cases of neglect on the part of parents who choose not to take their children to get medical attention when they need it for fear and shame that they will be recognized as intersex. This is a clear indication of a society that only accepts the existence of only two sexes and that a human being can either be male or female and nothing else. O course, the existence of intersex persons challnges that notion.

 Where a person makes a choice to change their sex and gender, they are also ostracized and ridiculed if not physically attacked for their choice. There are glaring policy gaps within the Kenyan health, legal and education systems in addressing the needs of both the transgender and intersex persons. For instance, early this year a transgender woman approached a doctor for gender reassignment therapy but the doctor informed her that such medical interventions were illegal in Kenya. This is misinformation that is feared-based. A few weeks later, the director of Kenyatta National Hospital canceled a surgical procedure for a Transgender woman reason been he wanted a no objection letter from the parents of the transgender woman. Efforts for the 25 year old transgender woman, to have the surgery rescheduled were thwarted by the Minister of Medical Services. Kenya’s Medical Practitioners and Dentists Board finally agreed to handle the matter but there are a few elements with the board whose religious fanaticism is marring the process. The doctors especially the psychiatrists, endocrinologists, urologists and gynecologists agree that creation of guidelines would provide a more expedite way of doing things but then activists have the role of creating awareness in Kenya’s communities so that the issue ceases to be an emotive issue to a medical issue grounded on human rights for all.

The level of ignorance on matters related to the intersex people is alarming. To make matters worse, the social environment has been hostile to intersex children and adults. Consequently, parents of intersex children have a social and psychological emergency with regard to raising these children in a society firmly fixed on the sex dichotomy: boy or girl.  In June this year, an intersex person got into a fight with his cousin because of constant taunts about his genitalia. He beat up the cousin till he was unconscious. In retaliation, the members of the public ganged up and gave him a thorough beating. They later on tied him up  and handed him to the police.

In June 2009, a transgender and intersex activist did a video interview with Ghetto Radio. The reporter did a follow up and went to collect views from the members of the public. What came out is sheer ignorance, arrogance and intolerance towards transgender and intersex concepts. All the interviewees gave what they deemed as “expert” opinions which are obviously wrought and perverted.

Violence against transgender women and intersex people is alarming. Two weeks ago, a transgender woman was attacked by members of the public along Tom Mboya Street in Nairobi. I am not sure where we expect them to go. They are human beings and the pavements and the streets that we use in our country, are for them too!

There are also cases of general harassment and humiliation of transgender persons.  In cases where someone violates their rights, the police do not intervene and even when they do, they turn the issue around and accuse the transgender persons of various petty crimes including impersonation. Two months ago, robbers invaded a home of a transgender woman. They got away with a water pump and when she reported the case some suspects were arrested. A day later, the police released the suspects and went to arrest the transgender woman because she is a “female impersonator”.

 In July 2009, Kenya Human Rights Commission sent a human rights activist to collect data on an intersex child in Kisii whose father was distressed by the amount of hostility his child was been subjected to by members of the public. The interview with the father and the six year old child was shocking. Despite the child’s condition, the father had no information on the condition of his child and had subjected the child to a number of surgical procedures that rendered the child incapable of controlling urine flow. The child aspires to be a pilot but its worth noting he faced so much hostility in school he had to drop out. We have to let his dream of becoming a pilot come true- by being more tolerant of differences and diversities. 


Share/Save

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Re: say no to discrimination

I am amazed. I am happy that you guys understand this plight. Its a fight that we must keep on. Just as the Black Americans fought for recognition, just as Women fought, and still continue to fight for recognition, we must keep on fighting. Our motive is plain and simple. Human beings are different and diverse. We should embrace this and accept that Normal is Abnormal, and viceversa. Truth is subjective. Let people live their own lives, make their own decisions and most of all, be treated with human dignity and respect. Whether its just one person out of a million, the 999,999 other persons must ensure that the one person's rights as a human being are not infringed upon.

"Live & Let Live - We are ALL Unique!"

When it is not me....

The unfortunate fight in the fight for right is that many of the times there is an attitude of ...now that it is not me...' and we fail to realise that Human rights are basic entitlements and freedoms to which all humans are entitled to....just becasue they are human... Many times there is a temptation to ignore rights of some people after all 'I am not affected' then we fail to realise the abuse of rights of any indivindual regardless of the situation is an indication of general violation of rights  in the society hence when we condone abuse of a minority groups rights, like LGBTIs we are creating the path for abuse of others' rights....including you!! Like the peace advocate said...they came for them..but I kept quiet so by the time they came for me.."

There is need to BREAK THE SILENCE

 

The number of violations on

The number of violations on transgender and intersex men and women is astounding! It is sad that the community would rather lock up, mock, burn or end theses peoples lives than be seen to accept them or give them space within our communities. The father and many other parents seem to want a quick fix to avoid a "bad image" but what about the suffering of the boy and what about his rights.

The society is still deep rooted in ensuring that the world remains "Normal". A term I heard alot during and just after the worls social forum in Nairobi. Many young LGBTI youth were given the opportunity to openly share about their expetiences and sexuality and as a result they were mocked on television and some termed them as "abnormal acts" and "confused kids". So for majority of kenyans Normal means MALE OR FEMALE peroid.

I took my national identification card for granted because come to think of it when I fill the forms to process it it states male of female. for my passport, insurance and other documents that are most important I MUST be male or female period. This does not allow for trans gender or intersex persons to fill these forms of if they do it would have to be in an illegitimate way. 

It is a struggle and I agree with Myra we must continue to sensitize our communities and speak up about these issues.

We have a long way to go to ensure equality and justice for our sisters and brothers!

Thank you for this Saida!

Re: say no to discrimination

@Nicole. The issues you raise in regards to the identity card and other forms that we are usually expected to fill in to ensure the processing of our entitlements are the greatest pointer to the discrimination that the transgender and intersex persons encounter. Our system does not acknowledge them at all; whether in school, accessing buildings eg security checks/ documents to access spaces etc. Once in a KLM flight when filling in some survey they randomly dished out, I put a dash on the question on female/ Male. It was very deliberate...I was just tired of this. It was also happening at a time I had sensitized myself on transgener and intersex issues. The big question is what do you do when your child is intersex? What do you do when a sister, brother, or your own child decides to change their sex and gender?

truely this are happenings

truely this are happenings that are kept a secret and it is sad.

the society needs to be sensetized on transgender issues and real life cases shared so that its not seen as 'NGO's' and 'activist'  trying to push thier own agenda in community. for real the child from Kisii should not be stopped from becoming a pilot.